Thanks so much for all the information! After looking at pictures of other decks stained with twp cedartone, I think it looks the way it should, I'm just not crazy about it. We're going to leave it for now, see if it grows on us. When it's ready for a new coat of twp, we'll use a different color or tweak a color (after testing) and yes, maybe hire a professional who knows what to expect with different types of woods and finishes.
Do other people agree with Jarrod that twp rustic is a pain to work with? Of the twp 100 series colors what would you guys consider a medium brown? Dark oak looks really dark...
Thanks again-- great forum.
Karen